AO Auction Recap – New York: Christie’s Impressionist and Modern Evening Sale, May 12th, 2016

May 13th, 2016

The Modigliani Sells, via Art ObservedThe Modigliani Sells, via Art Observed

After a long week of sales that has seen both ups and downs for the two main auction houses, Christie’s has concluded its week with a consistently solid Impressionist and Modern sale, with 7 of the 54 lots at auction going unsold for a final tally of $141,532,000.   The auction house saw its momentary stumbles over the course of the sale, with several pieces falling well below estimate, and a few high-profile lots going unsold.  Even so, Christie’s managed to keep the bids moving, and keep works selling, a point that surely is not lost on those watching Sotheby’s occasionally disheartening sale earlier this week.

Claude Monet, Le bassin aux nymphéas (1919), via Christie's
Claude Monet, Le bassin aux nymphéas (1919), via Christie’s

A Henry Moore sculpture opened the evening, yet saw bidders drop out as the lot price rose, ultimately falling just inside its estimate for a final of $461,000, while a Francis Picabia piece from 1929 beat estimate for a final of $2,629,000.  A Fernand Léger in the next lot took some coaxing to reach estimate, selling at $3,189,000, yet a Barbara Hepworth sculpture saw strong bids that fell just short of the artist’s auction record, reaching $5,429,000.  The Amedeo Modigliani lot came shortly after, selling immediately at low estimate for a final of $12,765,000.  A Picasso piece followed and sold on a single bid for a final of $8,005,000.

Christie's Showroom, via Art Observed
Christie’s Showroom, via Art Observed

The sale maintained momentum through a second round of high-priced lots, despite a Magritte painting passing at lot 12, bringing up a strong Pierre Bonnard that met estimate for $785,000, followed by a Claude Monet that went well below estimate for a final of $11,365,000.  A Georges Braque work saw more interest, creeping up and over its estimate thanks to multiple bidders, to reach $10,245,000, followed shortly after by a Frida Kahlo work that just squeaked into estimate range with a $8,005,000 final, nevertheless setting a new world record for the artist.  Several lots later, Claude Monet’s Le bassin aux nymphéas reached estimate and sold for a final of $27,045,000, while a Cézanne sold under estimate several lots later for $3,413,000.  A Renoir at lot 31 was one of the evening’s few passes.

Amedeo Modigliani, Jeune femme à la rose (Margherita) 91916), via Christie's
Amedeo Modigliani, Jeune femme à la rose (Margherita) (1916), via Christie’s

As the sale wound down, the auction house continued to push through, beating estimate on an Alberto Giacometti for $1,565,000, while a Picasso canvas saw strong interest to push it within estimate for a final of $2,629,000.  A Renoir would pass shortly after, before the sale closed on a string of moderately priced lots.

Andreas Rumbler briefs the press, via Art Observed
Andreas Rumbler briefs the press, via Art Observed

In the wake of this week’s auctions, predicting market health seems to be anyone’s game, as strong Contempoary sales complicate the picture against faltering Impressionist interest.  One can anticipate plenty of opinions in the coming days, as the auction market calms down for the summer months.

Barbara Hepworth, Sculpture with Color (1946), via Christie's
Barbara Hepworth, Sculpture with Colour (1946), via Christie’s

— D. Creahan

Read more:
Christie’s Impressionist and Modern Evening Sale [Christie’s]